Bad Ideas, Community, Cultural Traits, Culture, Death, Dying, Ethics, Human Nature, Ideas, John McCain, Life, Meaning, Morality, Morals, News and Current Events, Obligations to Society, Politics, Society, Values

“Speak No Ill of the Dead”

(About a 3 minute read)

The recent death and funeral of John McCain has once again raised a debate about the propriety of speaking ill of the dead.  Naturally, the loudest voices have belonged to partisan pundits who can be expected to flip their opinions — pro and con — when the next prominent Democrat dies.

But I think a lot of common people are concerned with the issue too.  How fair is it to criticize the dead?  If it’s fair at all, then does our criticism have limits?  And if so, what should those limits be?

I do not recall how the deaths of prominent politicians were handled when I was growing up 50 or so years ago, but I do recall that in the matter of members of my community, the rule was strict (and strictly obeyed) that one should never criticize the newly dead.

The community back then could be in general agreement that the only good quality you possessed were a fine set of teeth, and yet,  no one would even whisper a criticism of you until perhaps some considerable time after your burial.  I worked in a funeral home while in high school, and I cannot recall anyone criticizing the dead in all four years I worked there.

Of course, the death of prominent politicians is a whole ‘nother game.  To many folks, praising a politician amounts to praising his or her politics, criticizing them amounts to criticizing their politics.  And admonishing people to “speak no ill of the dead” amounts to unfairly playing the referees.

I do not think it is reasonable for one side to both insist on praising a man or woman’s politics, and that no one should speak ill of them.  Nor do I think it’s likely that we in our age will ever fail to use a funeral as an occasion to advance our own politics or condemn someone else’s politics by proxy of the deceased.   So I’m pretty confident that the old rule, “speak no ill of the dead” is at least partly compromised today, and will for the foreseeable future remain at least partly compromised.

But should we speak ill of the person themselves, apart from their politics?

I believe we should not, and my reasons for saying that go well beyond mere politeness.  To me, death is among the most powerful reminders that we are all human.  Moreover, I believe we forget that at our peril.  No republic or democracy can long survive if and when the sides demonize each other.  It is then that cooperation and magnanimity come to an end.

Only obstructionism remains — and no country can be run by a powerful obstructionist opposition.  History shows, the natural tendency of people under such a situation has been to seek out a strongman to end the obstructionism — at the price of freedoms and liberties.

Death is a solemn occasion not merely for the loss of life, and not merely for the suffering it brings to the deceased’s loved ones.  It is a solemn occasion because it is humanity’s fate to die.  But in that fact we may find that we are united by it.  Just as other things unite us — or should unite us — such as our love for our children and grandchildren, our love for our spouses and partners, and so forth — death unites us as one humanity.

It is all too easy for we humans to demonize each other —  to become beasts willing to rip out each other’s throats — without adding to the problem by denying or refusing to honor the marks of our common humanity.

So, while I would be willing to criticize a prominent man or woman’s politics even on the day of their funeral, I will reserve any criticism of the person themselves for a more appropriate time.

Questions? Comments?

7 thoughts on ““Speak No Ill of the Dead””

  1. I must say I can agree, but when it comes to politicians, everything is on the table. They make decisions that impact people, possibly forever. With that being said, if people want to slander me when I have passed, go for it, it ain’t gonna bother me none. Those same politicians would be doing the happy dance if trump fell over dead. None of them are true and none of them care, that’s why they are falling all over themselves to speak, it’s more airtime for their platform. Disgusting, never let an opportunity pass though, right.


    1. I believe I can see your case for putting everything on the table when it comes to politicians. I regard that as a personal decision — there’s no right or wrong way, so far as I can see. I choose to avoid criticizing the deceased as a person for a period after their death. But in my book, you or anyone else have every right to do so.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. They once sang his applause
    Thinking he was Santa Claus
    Shamelessly he didn’t even pause
    He kept on sharpening his white claws………
    Whoops, I’m a downunderer, maybe I got me the wrong man..


I'd love to hear from you. Comments make my day.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s